Its possible to get through gone girl in a matter of. Mar 16, 2015 fbi vet candice delong examines gone girl s amy dunne, diagnosing her with munchausen syndrome. Hes probably one of the most ambiguous characters in the book. In the book, amy drugs desi before cutting his throat and murdering him. A majority of the characters have ulterior motives and are trying to use each other to serve their own selfish ends, though of course amy takes the cake when it comes to disingenuousness. Sep 30, 2014 earlier this year, many fans of gillian flynns 2012 thriller gone girl were dismayed to learn that the author had changed the storys ending for the film adaptation. While hes out at work, she clearly stages what looks like a brutal rape.
Gone girl is the movie flynn fans hoped for and sets pike up for a worthy oscar nomination but fincher disappoints in failing to improve upon the alreadybrilliant book. And so were going to let you in on a little secret. Desis mom is also cut out of the book, which means we dont get. Considering both answers are by users who havent experienced both book and movie ill say my peace or is the phrase ill say my piece.
Honestly, the movie played out extremely well and had a nice running compatibility with the book. Welcome to gone girl, where everyone is an asshole. At one point in gone girl, the preposterous desi talks of quitting america for greece. This scene is about 15 seconds long, and is a panning shot. Fbi vet candice delong examines gone girls amy dunne, diagnosing her with munchausen syndrome. In the book, amy drugs desi before cutting his throat and murdering. This scene is brief but strong, and is about 10 seconds long. There are many spoilers in gone girl book to movie comparison. Why gone girls amy dunne is the most disturbing female villain of all time psych of a psycho duration. Nick and amy have fully clothed sex on a table in the middle of a library. Gone girl is a thriller novel in the mystery and crime genres, by the american writer gillian flynn. Gillian flynn is a fantastic writer who writes with an eccentric edge that does not appeal to. May 30, 2015 desi s mom seemed to be protective of her son and dismissed nick saying that the next time nick wants to talk to desi, he should go through their lawyer. Oct 06, 2014 in fact, the movie version was even a little more infuriating in how she gets away with a coldblooded murder.
When she calls on creepy desi collings neil patrick harris in the movie, she does so in a casino. During the preparation process for a standard anniversary which includes the wrapping of presents and creation of reservations. Here are all the big differences between gone girl the. Nick and amy have fully clothed doggy style sex against a wall in their upstairs hallway.
The greatest movie plot twists of all time duration. Why gone girl s amy dunne is the most disturbing female villain of all time psych of a psycho duration. The novel became quite popular and soon made the new york times best seller list. In fact, the movie version was even a little more infuriating in how she gets away with a coldblooded murder. Not everybody has the time or the inclination to read a 400page book in a week. It is completely messed up and an absolute mindfuck, but its one hell of a ride. How different was gone girls most gruesome scene in the book. In the book, amy drops the charges, because the assault never happened she made it up. Set in missouri, the story begins as a mystery that follows the events surrounding nick dunne affleck, who becomes the prime suspect in the sudden.
So desis outright hate towards nick in the movie was maybe to compensate with the lack of desis moms character in the film. The film version of gone girl, which hit theaters this weekend, follows the. The very, very spoiled edition if youve already read gone girl, or if you dont mind swimming in a sea of spoilers, weve got a few thoughts that require giving up some of. The book gone girl written by gillian flynn begins in north carthage, missouri. Gone girl, book to movie comparison hannahsbeautyandhair. Which is the better version of gone girl by gillian flynn. Amy slips sleeping pills into the martini she insists on making for desi. As gone girl rolled through production, there was talk about director david fincher and screenwriter gillian flynn tinkering with and possibly changing the ending to the authors bestselling. Oct 08, 2014 back in january, entertainment weekly ran a cover story on the then upcoming adaptation of gillian flynns bestselling novel gone girl. Sure, im going to tear apart the movie and some of the things that were changed from the book, but ultimately it was the best book to movie adaptation i have ever saw.
David finchers gone girl 2014 is a stylized thriller with chilling surprises. The image of his hand caressing a womans sleek blond hair in. Finchers direction complements her writing with his sleek, smooth camera shots of clear violence and open sexuality. Gone girl was a hugely popular book that sold millions of copies. Major differences between the gone girl book and movie huffpost.
The book will always be better than the movie overall. Despite the fact that flynn wrote the screenplay for david finchers new film, there are a. Its an extreme form of rebellion, but an interesting. Oct 06, 2014 the differences between the ending of gone girl, the film, and gone girl, the book, are miniscule. Gone girl is finally in theaters this weekend, and the adaptation is remarkably. Desi collings sheesh, what is it with all these characters having relationships with people that are stalkerish, possessive freaks. Pdf gone girl by gillian flynn book download online. Today, im comparing the gone girl book with the movie.
Mar 02, 2015 a thematic analysis of gone girl 2014. If i had to give gone girl a tag line, it would be. David finchers movie is a master class in how to handle a book. The biggest differences between the gone girl movie and book. She soaks her nightgown in red wine, binds her hands and feet, then crawls to the camera, crying, making it look like shes just been raped.
Oct 04, 2014 heres for a full comment piece involving spoilers on gone girl and its portrayal of women. Desis ultimate whiteknight fantasy is pretty close to what actually happens. Oct 04, 2014 the biggest differences between the gone girl movie and the book. Major differences between the gone girl book and movie. The film stars ben affleck, rosamund pike, neil patrick harris, and tyler perry.
Here, where people familiar with the movie expect a quickly drawn box cutter, the book takes a more lowkey path. Desi, drama and third act plotholes neil patrick harris, who plays desi collings. In the book, at least desis mother goes to the police, hysterical, saying that amy. Amy eventually runs to her high school boyfriend, desi collings, then kills him and makes it look like an escape from a dangerous captor.
Gone girls ending is different from the book in these. If you havent read gone girl, steer clear of the below. David fincher handled the challenge of adapting a beloved novel with aplomb in gone girl, managing to fit gillian flynns intricate mystery within the very different confines of a movie. Mar 28, 2015 sure, im going to tear apart the movie and some of the things that were changed from the book, but ultimately it was the best book to movie adaptation i have ever saw. Desi collings, please join amy elliott dunne and andie hardy in the dysfunctional significant other bullpen. Heres for a full comment piece involving spoilers on gone girl and its portrayal of women.
If you have, well, prepare yourself for the missing ingredients or compare your book vs. Tommy tells nick hes now legally obligated to identify himself as a sexual offender. Jacqueline collings is the mother of desi, and the two actually live together in the novel. If you checked out gone girl this weekend and based on the box. Oct 08, 2014 the book version of gone girl, so ive heard, is a crime novel. So please if you have not read the book or seen the movie come back later when you do. Back in january, entertainment weekly ran a cover story on the then upcoming adaptation of gillian flynns bestselling novel gone girl. Jul, 2015 gone girl book vs gone girl movie hello everyone. The book starts with the celebration of nick dunne and amy dunnes wedding anniversary, notably their 5th one. At desi s home, amy learns that desi has security cameras installed all over the property. Not just literally, as in the sicko punch and judy puppets amy gets nick for their anniversary, but metaphorically.
Desis mom is also cut out of the book, which means we dont get to hear her scream about amy being the crazy one near the end. I just finished gillian flynns gone girl after weeks of only being able to read a little bit at a time. Why you should read or reread gone girl before seeing. Gone girl the movie starred a well played ben affleck as nick, and rosamund pike made for a perfect amy.
There a new life awaitsoctopus and scrabble, he says. But dont be surprised to see some changes in the onscreen adaptation of the beloved gillian flynn book. Cool girl amy by nick, beautiful and doting amy by desi. The sense of suspense in the novel comes from whether or not nick dunne is involved in the disappearance of his wife amy. Gone girl is a 2014 american psychological thriller film directed by david fincher and with a screenplay by gillian flynn based on her 2012 novel of the same title. They chose all of the actors perfectly, and they truly did a better job turning a book into a movie than a lot of other movies based off of books ive seen. The film concludes with amy and nick going on television to announce amys pregnancy, as opposed. I would say the movie was 90% accurate to the book, and thats a big amount of correctness. I went to the movie with two friends, one who had read the book and one who has not.
In the movie, she does it midsex with blood spilling all over her, her white bra and the white bed. It opened this weekend at number 1 barely holding off horror flick annabelle with 38 million dollars. Earlier this year, many fans of gillian flynns 2012 thriller gone girl were dismayed to learn that the author had changed the storys ending for the film adaptation. Desis mom seemed to be protective of her son and dismissed nick saying that the next time nick wants to talk to desi, he should go through their lawyer. Desi was amys boyfriend at prep school, and while things between them went pretty well for about a year, he eventually started creeping her outhe talked as if they were engaged, he knew the number and gender. Today we will be talking about gone girl, now i know everyone has read this or seen the film but as usual i caught on to the hype behind everyone else i have a huge selection of books to be read and i buy more each month so i just randomly select from the pile, gone girl sat in that pile for an. Oct 03, 2014 there are many spoilers in gone girl book to movie comparison. When amy gets to his house, its obvious that hes been planning for awhile to bring her therehes painted her wouldbe bedroom her favorite color and even built a greenhouse where tulips, the flower she loved in high school, will bloom year round. Sep 24, 2014 not everybody has the time or the inclination to read a 400page book in a week. Here are all the big differences between gone girl the book and gone girl the movie. While desi has nothing but love for amy, jacqueline. While the movie boasts a laundry list of accolades, the book arguably offers a more intimate and enthralling experience for audiences. So desi s outright hate towards nick in the movie was maybe to compensate with the lack of desi s moms character in the film.
Desi collings mom, jacqueline, rightly accuses amy of murdering desi. But that doesnt mean the movie isnt better than the. Gone girl book vs gone girl movie sparkles of light. The author, gillian flynn, sold the rights to 20th century fox and, soon after, the great david fincher came on to direct. This was my second time reading this book, which is why it was easy for me to decide which novel to pick for this assignment. Gone girl, the latest from that dark lord of cinema, david fincher, opens with a man softly talking about his wifes head. Despite the fact that flynn wrote the screenplay for david finchers new film, there are a few small plot twists that didnt make the cut.
272 671 627 192 56 648 443 1366 1190 403 1618 738 1250 368 629 1199 1247 174 1077 1188 1636 1113 760 643 1648 88 930 160 1053 999 551 1462 1181 566 112 325 341